
escapiiist
- November 12th, 2007
The film Boys Don't Cry is a very powerful one. It is based on the true story of Teena Brandon, a young woman who is struggling with her sexual identity. In the beginning of the movie, she cuts her hair and dresses like a man to see if she can actually pull it off. It started out as a social experiment, but ended up being an alter ego as she was finally "accepted" by a group of people she met at a bar. The movie basically follows Teena Brandon and her new found friends escapades - including her falling in love with a girl names Lana. (Who falls in love with her too, without the knowledge of her being a woman.) Unfortunately, her past mistakes caught up with her when she was caught at the bank and placed in the female cell in jail.
This movie, in all its power and simplicity is impressive because unlike other movies that shy away from the disturbing details - Boy's Don't Cry does not. In fact, this movie may seem disturbing because it goes directly into explaining and expounding the elaborate and somewhat sordid details of what it's really like to be in the shoes of the protagonist - a transgendered 21 year old.
When I first saw this film, which was about, 5 years ago, I was deeply disturbed and bothered by how direct and honest it was that I couldn't contnue watching it anymore. I had decided to finish the movie just last year as it helped in my understanding of my major class in Psychology. I guess the most compelling part of this film is how even if it focused on the transgender phenomenon, I can say that even if I'm not experiencing the exact same problem - I can acknowledge some aspects of my life that I do not understand. The things I'd loved to change and the things that make me feel like a complete outsider from the society I am supposedly a part of. In the case of Teena, being a transgendered was her being a man trapped inside a woman's body. Though this may seem harder to grasp than "normal" problems that we experience what we certainly can agree on is the feeling of not belonging. Through Teena's trying to belong she paid the price because in the year 1993 in Nebraska, she was brutally murdered - for being different.
I guess the initial question I had was "What is this movie really about?" If you ask a lot of people what the movie is about, they'll tell you it's about lesbianism or courage or transgenderedness. But if you were to ask me, I'd say it was more of identity - not jsut about sexual identity, more like a deeper understanding of the self. If you think about it, quite possibly, all the characters in this film were either lost, confused or just not paying much attention to what their lives mean. The thing is, as a viewer of the film, I noticed that the only person who was having conflicts with herself/himself was Brandon. Everyone else was aloof or didn't bother with their identity issues cause they were too busy drinking theirselves silly! Anyway, so as soon as they found out that Brandon - the person they thought they all knew and loved for who he supposedly was was really a woman, it shook them. Not only because their trust in him was broken, but the mere fact that Brandon was sturggling with his identity could possibly have affected everyone elses struggle with their own. So, instead of completely ignoring their identity issues, it grew into massive proportions and blew up in their faces.
My next question would be "Why did Brandon have to go through the extent of risking his life just so he could be happy?" I mean I understood his case at the beginning, you know. He stayed so he could figure out his situation in life and to forget about his past mistakes. But, how can he ever come to terms with what's at present if he can't even manage or try to rectify what he's done before? I would understand if he just decided to go because it wasn't working out anymore. Remember, he had the chance to leave already. But he still decided to stay. That was stupid. If what he already had done were stupid, he just added to it by acting on impulse and possibly HORMONES! He should have left when he had the chance. In the movie, I understood that for him and Lana, it was "love". But I mean, if it's meant to be, it's meant to be. He stayed because he loved Lana and there was no one else for him. Did he want to prove something to himself? To others? Yes, I understood that it was the identity crisis, yes I understood that he was trying to feel if he was finally comfortable with his choice. But still, these are the moments in peoples lives were other people who are part of it, or who know what the other person is going through think to themselves - "Sayang, there could have been a better outcome for you!" He was so deeply consumed by the "love" or good feeling that he had concerning Lana that he was naive to how it turned into an obsession. Obsessions aren't good, cause the possible outcome of it is bad.
I have no questions regarding his being transgendered as it was already explained to me by one of my Psychology professors. Which is a reason for my calling Brandon or referring to Brandon/Teena as a "he". These transgendered people aren't lesbian or gay, they feel as if they were born the wrong gender. So, for the sake and in honor of Teena Brandon's memory, I will refer to her as a "he".
I guess I agree on the search for identity answer. Mostly because through this film, I also saw myself. As of now, I'm 20. I'm nearing the age Teena Brandon was when s/he was brutally murdured. And I guess, when a tragedy happens or is about to happen, you prepare yourself for it. A lot of things you wouldn't normally think about or focus on will arise and you're left to deal. Which is why I felt for Teena. I'm in that age and I'm stuck wondering if who I am now is who I'm supposed to be. If who I am trying to be is what I'm really supposed to be. This movie taught me how that even if I'm different from others, that doesn't make me bad or unwanted. It just makes me who I am. And if that bothers some people, if they can't take who I am - then that's their loss. Because as far as I'm concerned, although I'm not totally sure of myself, I'm fine. Because right now, whoever passes judgment on me is not worth thinking of or worrying about. If they're talking bad about me behind my back, then that's their insecurity. Because I'm comfortable with the now - the me now too. I think it's safe to say that if they aren't okay with me it's either because they're still troubled with who they are themselves or because I'm content with myself and they aren't.
I just have to disagree with the answer of the second. I know it wouldn't be the same now if I were to place myself in Brandon's position, because no matter what I say it will have no effect on him, or anyone part of this story. The past is the past right, what we have now, what I have now is just enough to work with to get through the present and what the future will bring. We learn from mistakes right? So, with this, end my reasoning.
"Dear Lana, By the time you read this I'll be back home in Lincoln. I'm scared of what's ahead, but when I think of you I know I'll be able to go on. You were right, Memphis isn't that far off. I'll be taking that trip down the highway before too long. I'll be waiting for you. Love always and forever, Brandon."
- Every time I remember this last scene in the movie, a part of me just breaks. IF ONLY. If only she used her mind and left when she had the chance to. Now all we have is the memory and the numerous what-if's were left to wonder about.